A question on nearly every patient’s mind is, “Can I Avoid Back Surgery?” And my steadfast response is, “If pain is your surgeon’s single justification to operate, I’d get a second opinion.”
I have been practicing chiropractic for more than 28 years, and I have heard just about every description of back pain imaginable. Some patients describe a dull ache that never seems to go away. Others have sharp, shooting pain that makes getting out of a chair an event requiring considerable planning. And then there are those who arrive in my office carrying an MRI report, a surgical recommendation, and the understandable fear that somebody is about to rearrange the architecture of their spine.
It happened again last week at my chiropractic clinic in San Mateo. A woman walked in using a cane. She stated she has been experiencing lower back pain following a car accident. She had been referred to an orthopedic surgeon by her insurance company, and surgery was already being recommended. Naturally, she was frightened, and one of the first things she asked me was, “Dr. Quarneri, can I avoid back surgery?” What concerned me wasn’t necessarily the recommendation itself, but whether the underlying cause of her pain had been sufficiently established to justify it.
I explained that it depends on what is actually wrong with your back. I know that isn’t the wonderfully reassuring answer people want to hear, but after nearly three decades treating spinal problems, I have learned that the most important part of deciding whether someone needs surgery is understanding precisely what we’re treating.
Many neurosurgeons and orthopedic surgeons will tell you that back pain, by itself, is not a diagnosis or a sufficient reason to operate. And I agree with them.
Pain tells us that something is wrong, but it does not necessarily tell us what is wrong, why it is happening, or whether surgery is the appropriate solution. That distinction matters enormously, particularly when the treatment being considered involves permanently changing part of your spine.
Back Pain Is a Symptom, Not a Surgical Diagnosis
Consider something as ordinary as a headache. You wouldn’t expect a physician to recommend surgery simply because your head hurts. You would expect an examination, some questions, perhaps diagnostic testing if the circumstances warranted it, and an effort to identify the cause.
Back pain deserves the same consideration… There are numerous structures in and around the spine capable of producing pain, including muscles, ligaments, spinal discs, facet joints, and irritated nerves. Sometimes the problem involves more than one of these structures, which makes diagnosis considerably more interesting than the average patient would prefer.
For example, a person with a herniated lumbar disc might experience pain traveling through the buttock and down one leg. Another person with restricted or irritated facet joints may have significant lower back pain without any leg symptoms. Someone with spinal stenosis might feel relatively comfortable sitting down but develop pain, heaviness, or weakness in the legs after walking a short distance.
All three patients might tell me that they have terrible back pain. Yet the underlying problems, examination findings, and appropriate treatments could be very different.
This is one reason I have always placed so much emphasis on neurological function and spinal movement. As a Board Certified Chiropractic Neurologist, I’m interested not only in where something hurts but also in how the nervous system is functioning, how the joints are moving, and what compensations the body has developed in response.
Until we understand those things, discussing surgery may be getting ahead of ourselves.
Does an MRI Showing a Herniated Disc Mean I Need Surgery?
This is where things become especially interesting… I have seen patients become understandably alarmed after reading an MRI report containing words such as degeneration, disc bulge, herniation, or spinal stenosis. Medical terminology has a remarkable ability to make an otherwise perfectly reasonable person imagine that their spine is preparing to collapse.
But an MRI is a picture of anatomy. It is not, by itself, a complete explanation of someone’s pain.
Disc degeneration and other structural changes become increasingly common as we age. Some people have significant abnormalities on imaging and experience little or no discomfort. Others have substantial pain despite relatively modest imaging findings.
That doesn’t mean an MRI is unimportant. Far from it. When the clinical circumstances call for imaging, it can provide valuable information about disc injuries, nerve compression, spinal stenosis, and other conditions.
What matters is whether the findings correspond with the patient’s symptoms and neurological examination.
If an MRI shows a herniated disc pressing against a particular nerve root, and the patient has matching leg pain, sensory changes, or weakness, we have a much clearer clinical picture. If the report identifies several degenerative changes that don’t correspond with the symptoms, we need to be cautious about assuming those changes are responsible.
I often remind patients that we are treating a human being, not a radiology report.
When Is Back Surgery Actually Necessary?
I want to be clear about something: I am not opposed to spinal surgery.
There are excellent neurosurgeons and orthopedic spine surgeons performing procedures that can make an enormous difference in people’s lives. There are also circumstances when postponing necessary surgery can lead to serious consequences.
Progressive neurological weakness, certain forms of significant nerve compression, spinal instability, and other serious spinal conditions may warrant surgical intervention. New bladder or bowel dysfunction, numbness in the saddle area, or rapidly worsening leg weakness can signal a neurological emergency requiring immediate medical evaluation.
These are not situations where someone should spend six months trying various treatments in the hope that things will eventually improve.
Even without an emergency, surgery may be appropriate when disabling symptoms persist despite reasonable nonsurgical care and the clinical findings identify a problem that an operation is likely to improve.
In my opinion, the important question isn’t whether someone can tolerate another few months of pain. It is whether we have identified a specific condition for which surgery offers a meaningful benefit, and whether less invasive approaches remain reasonable.
Those are conversations worth having carefully, preferably before anyone schedules an operating room.
Can Spinal Decompression Help Avoid Back Surgery?
For selected patients, nonsurgical spinal decompression may be one option worth considering.
At Quarneri Chiropractic in San Mateo, spinal decompression is among the treatments we use for appropriate spinal conditions. It involves applying controlled traction to the spine, with the goal of reducing mechanical loading and helping certain patients manage symptoms associated with disc-related problems.
It is important to distinguish this type of nonsurgical decompression from the surgical procedures that may be used to relieve significant pressure on spinal nerves. Despite sharing a name, they are very different treatments.
Nonsurgical spinal decompression is not a cure for every herniated disc, and the scientific evidence supporting its effectiveness is limited and mixed. It cannot correct serious spinal instability or replace an indicated operation.
However, after an appropriate evaluation, it may be considered as one component of a conservative care program for certain patients. Chiropractic care, appropriately selected exercises, rehabilitation, and strategies for improving spinal mobility may also play roles, depending on the diagnosis.
My objective is not to convince every patient that chiropractic treatment can replace surgery. That would be medically irresponsible and, frankly, contrary to everything I have learned from treating patients over the years.
My objective is to determine whether there is a reasonable opportunity to improve function without an operation, while recognizing when a surgical consultation is necessary.
The Relationship Between Sciatica, Nerve Pain, and Back Surgery
Sciatica is another condition that frequently sends people into my office worried about surgery.
The pain can be extraordinary. Patients describe burning, electrical sensations, numbness, and discomfort radiating from the lower back or buttock into the leg. Sitting becomes uncomfortable, driving becomes an endurance test, and sleeping through the night suddenly seems like a luxury.
It isn’t unusual for someone to assume that pain of this intensity must mean something is permanently damaged. Fortunately, that is not always the case.
Many cases of sciatica improve with time and appropriate conservative treatment. Depending on the cause, management may include activity modification, exercise-based rehabilitation, medication prescribed by a medical clinician, and selected forms of manual therapy. Some patients may benefit from additional medical interventions.
The complication is that sciatica describes a pattern of symptoms rather than identifying one specific underlying condition. A herniated disc may be responsible, but spinal stenosis or other causes of nerve irritation can produce similar complaints.
The presence of pain alone does not tell us whether a patient needs surgery. Progressive weakness, neurological deficits, functional limitations, the duration of symptoms, and imaging findings all contribute to that decision.
This is why I don’t like seeing patients frightened into believing that every painful episode of sciatica is another step toward an operating table.
Sometimes the Best Treatment Is Understanding Why Your Back Hurts
One of the more frustrating things about chronic back pain is how quietly it can begin to dictate someone’s life.
People stop playing golf because rotating their spine has become uncomfortable. They avoid long drives because sitting aggravates their symptoms. They give up skiing, tennis, hiking, or other activities that used to be a normal part of their lives.
Eventually, they become so accustomed to avoiding discomfort that they hardly recognize how much they have changed their routines.
I’ve always believed that movement is an essential part of maintaining health and independence. That philosophy played an important role in attracting me to chiropractic in the first place, and it remains central to how I evaluate patients today.
But maintaining movement isn’t simply a matter of telling someone to exercise more. If a person has a painful joint restriction, irritated nerve, or mechanical problem that makes certain movements difficult, we first need to understand those limitations.
Sometimes that means improving mobility in restricted joints. Sometimes it involves carefully rebuilding strength and tolerance for activity. Sometimes the appropriate decision is to refer someone for additional imaging, medical evaluation, or a surgical opinion.
And sometimes the best thing we can do is explain that a frightening-looking MRI does not necessarily mean the patient’s future includes back surgery.
At Quarneri Chiropractic, I’m joined by Dr. Pete Quigley and our newest associate chiropractor, Dr. Rami Shnoudi. Together, we evaluate patients dealing with sciatica, chronic spinal pain, joint restrictions, and other conditions affecting movement and neurological function.
Our responsibility is to recognize what we can reasonably help, what requires additional investigation, and what belongs in the hands of another specialist.
Before You Agree to Back Surgery, Ask the Right Questions
If someone has recommended spinal surgery, I encourage them to understand the diagnosis, the specific objective of the operation, the expected benefits and risks, and what might happen if they choose not to proceed immediately.
Ask what structure is causing the symptoms. Ask whether the imaging findings correspond with the examination. Ask which symptoms the procedure is intended to improve, what alternatives remain appropriate, and whether delaying surgery carries a neurological risk.
For nonemergency conditions, an independent second opinion can be valuable, particularly before an irreversible procedure.
I cannot promise that you will avoid back surgery. No responsible chiropractor, neurologist, or orthopedic surgeon should make that promise without understanding your condition.
What I can tell you is that pain alone does not settle the question.
If you’ve been struggling with back pain, sciatica, or reduced spinal mobility and are wondering whether nonsurgical treatment might be appropriate, schedule a consultation at Quarneri Chiropractic in San Mateo.
Book your consultation today — We’ll evaluate your symptoms, examine how your spine and nervous system are functioning, review relevant diagnostic findings, and discuss what options may reasonably fit your condition. Because before deciding how to treat your back, we ought to understand why it hurts.
Quarneri Chiropractic – Chiropractor in San Mateo
📞 Call Now: (650) 375-2545
📅 Request an Appointment: Book Online
📍 Address: 177 Bovet Rd, Suite 150, San Mateo, CA



